Two-way vs One-way Protected Bikeways

What’s more important to you as someone who rides: your time and money or your safety and enjoyment?
 

Cities around the US are building modern protected bikeways that are safer and more enjoyable than the bike lanes and sharrows you grew up on. Across the US, traffic engineers are starting to separate you from traffic by placing the bikeway next to the curb away from traffic, and moving travel lanes and parking lanes out into the street, where they belong. By placing you next to the curb, you ride where you instinctively feel safer, and by keeping you there throughout your commute, you enjoy the experience more and are motivated to get back on your bike for your next ride, and encourage your friends to join you.

However, these protected bikeways can take longer to navigate and cost cities more money to build than regular bike lanes. Over time though, a built-out network of protected bikeways can save you time, as it does hundreds of thousands of Danes every day in Copenhagen who ride because it is quicker. Shown here is a brand new, state-of-the-art wide protected bikeway, or cycle track, going right into the heart of Downtown Copenhagen.

While riding a protected bikeway, you avoid double-parked trucks, and cars pulling into and out of parking spaces, and you also avoid jockeying with buses stopping to pick up passengers. All of this vehicle activity happens on your left away from the curb and away from you and your bikeway. By getting people out of traffic, protected bikeways are proving much safer and eminently more attractive to new riders, and are exploding across the US. They are the types of bikeways that people from 8 years old to 80 years old can enjoy.

new york protected bike lane.jpgSeveral cities in the East Bay are upgrading bikeways with buffered bike lanes and green paint-both much needed improvements that are not expensive at all. Some East Bay cities are designing protected bike lanes and safer intersections with bike boxes and bike traffic signals, which significantly improve your safety but start adding some cost to projects. However, only a few East Bay city have built parking-protected bike lanes like Chicago and New York are doing as a matter of course, much less a network of these facilities, which is what it takes to create mode shift from driving to bicycling. Shown here is the 9th Ave protected bike lane in Manhattan.

Current list of protected bike lanes in East Bay

  1. Shoreline Drive in Alameda
  2. Fernside Drive in Alameda
  3. Clement Avenue in Alameda
  4. Telegraph Ave in Oakland
  5. Broadway (above Keith) in Oakland
  6. Fulton Street in Berkeley
  7. Protected Intersection at The Alameda & Hopkins in Berkeley
  8. Grimmer Blvd in Fremont
  9. Canal Blvd in Richmond

Building protected bikeways is a trade off worth your input as we seek the optimum balance for tomorrow’s modern bikeways. To explain why, start by asking yourself which you would rather have: a lot more streets upgraded with regular bike lanes to make it safer for those currently bicycling, or a fewer number of streets upgraded with awesome protected bikeways that are safe for everyone to use–new bicyclists, kids, and senior citizens alike? Cities can build more of the former and fewer of the latter, given limited staff and money.

Bike lanes are cheap to stripe and work reasonably well for enthusiastic bicyclists comfortable using them. They are relatively quick to get around on—they don’t cost you a lot of time and can even save you some. Protected bikeways, on the other hand, require a more measured approach to safely getting you through busy intersections—you can’t get around in them quite as quickly but you get through them safely. Protected bikeways are also more enjoyable to use because you are physically separated from traffic and when built with a width of 8 ft or wider allow you to ride side-by-side with a friend. On 2-way protected bikeways you can high five your friends passing by the other way.

The question of 1-way protected bikeways vs 2-way protected bikeways takes your preferences to another level. 2-way protected bikeways are even more enjoyable to use, and arguably safer still, but they slow you down a little more and are costlier still to build. How much more are you willing to pay in time and money to improve your safety and enjoyment?

People who ride in New York City or Chicago are showing they are willing to pony up. But the jury seems to still be out on how much more. In some locations in these cities they are building 2-way protected bikeways and in other locations they have 1-way protected bikeways. Here in the East Bay, Alameda’s Shoreline Drive is a 2-way protected bikeway, while Telegraph Ave and Fulton Street are 1-way protected bike lanes. Which style protected bikeway is preferable?

One way vs Two way.png

Take a look at these photos.  The top photo shows a 2-way protected bikeway in Malmö, Sweden, in a dense part of town. It’s adjacent and raised up to the level of the sidewalk and was built on what used to be part of the roadway. On it, people ride on the same side of the street, on the 2-directional path, which means some people are bicycling against traffic, albiet separated from that traffic. It’s well-designed and has proven extremely popular, as 30% of trips are made by bike in Malmö. In fact, Sweden is the 4th most popular country for bicycling in the world and has one of the lowest collision rates of any country. 

Meanwhile, Copenhagenize is a design consultant in Copenhagen and a popular blogger on bicycling, and he hates 2-way cycle tracks, much preferring 1-way cycle tracks or protected bike lanes as we call them here in the States. The 1-way protected bike lane shown in photo 2 is on Frederiksborggade in Downtown Copenhagen. On this 1-way protected bikeway, you ride in the direction of traffic on your side of the street, while people bicycling in the other direction are on the other side of the street in a similar protected bike lane, kind of like the traffic flow with conventional bike lanes. Throughout Copenhagen, you ride with traffic on a network of these 1-way protected bikeways, through intersections thoughtfully designed for bicycling. 50% of trips are made by bike in Copenhagen. Germany also designs a lot of 1-way protected bike lanes and cities such as Münster and Freiburg have rates of bicycling as high as many Dutch cities.

Both 1-way and 2-way protected bike lanes can be ‘protected’ by parked cars, which adds an additional level of safety and comfort, and they can be raised partly or all the way up to the level of the curb, as shown in the above photos. And on both 1-way and 2-way facilities, you don’t feel like you are mixing with cars. At intersections, 1-way protected bikeways sometimes merge with right-turning traffic, although they don’t have to. They can remain segregated from turning traffic by extending the bike lane up to the intersection and providing bike traffic signals where needed to prevent cars from turning right while bikes go straight. Shown here is Copenhagen’s preference for extending the bike lane all the way up to the crosswalk, while maintaining a vehicle set back. On 2-way cycle tracks, there never is a merge zone and bike traffic signals are provided at every intersection. Either way, segregating turning movements of cars and bikes slows you down as you ride and is more costly to design and build, but is way safer and more enjoyable for most people.

Answering our question of preferences involves trading off your desire to save time and cities’ desires to save money vs your desire for increased comfort and cities’ desires to encourage more people to bicycle. 1-way protected bike lanes are less expensive than 2-way, and for this reason a city can build more of them. But they also are often designed to transition to merge zones at intersections to allow drivers to turn right. This mixing of traffic is familiar to many people who bike, but discourages many others who would ride but don’t because they feel it’s unsafe to ride with cars. It’s a bit of a compromise between accommodating people who currently ride with encouraging more to ride.

2-way protected bike lanes completely separate movement of cars and bikes at intersections. This approach is safer and certainly is ‘perceived’ as much safer, and is a bit more social as it allows you to ride side-by-side on a wider facility and chat while you ride or high five people riding the opposite way. However, it is also more expensive and adds time to your bike trips, as you have to wait at each intersection for your bike traffic signal green phase.

Popular European cities for bicycling, such as Amsterdam and Copenhagen, use both 1-way and 2-way protected bikeways, but Copenhagen has a strong preference for 1-way designs while Swedish cities seem to prefer 2-way designs. In the US, Indianapolis built a network of 2-way cycle paths throughout their downtown called the Indianapolis Cultural Trail. It sees high volumes of people walking and bicycling, and has been an economic boom to their city. However, it was expensive to build and for this reason is not quickly expanded and emulated on every bike route.Adeline and 14th Cafe view 800.jpg

Oakland is building 1-way protected bike lanes on Telegraph Ave, right through the heart of the KONO District, as is El Cerrito on San Pablo Ave. Oakland is also studying the feasibility of a road diet on 14th St through downtown, in order to make room for a protected bikeway connecting Lake Merritt with Mandela Parkway and eventually the Bay Bridge bike path. Should 14th St be 1-way or 2-way protected bike lanes. Here is one option showing a 2-way design.

As cities in the East Bay move forward designing separated, protected bikeways, they need to address a key decision—what should their bikeways of the future look like. The bikeways should stay along the curb, but whether they are 1-way vs. 2-way is a trade off of money vs encouraging more people to ride. Check out Alameda’s 2-way cycle track getting constructed on Shoreline Drive or ride the 1-way protected bike lanes on Market St, Fell and Oak in San Francisco, and start thinking about which you prefer. There’s no right answer at this point, but your thoughtful input can help direct the conversation forward.

Join Bike East Bay to support these campaigns. Help us build more modern bikeways for you to ride everyday.